I’m very upset with YouTube and am considering jumping ship.
I’ve used their video hosting services for well over three years and I currently have 86 videos uploaded to their site. I understood (somewhat) when they removed the sound from one of my videos that used a Barenaked Ladies tune as part of its soundtrack. But they have recently started deleting some of my videos “due to terms of use violation.” They have been flagged as “inappropriate” and have been completely removed from their servers along with all of the comments attached to them. These were videos of my daughter – one on the beach and one in the tub. In both videos, she was just one year and a few months old.
I disagree completely with the label of “inappropriate” that was slapped on these videos, the same way I am appalled at how Flickr has been deleting photos of mothers breastfeeding from people’s accounts without prior warning. I don’t mean to tempt fate, but the inconsistency of their rulings also has me baffled as YouTube has decided to leave a similar video of Emily in the bath online. I want to be able to share my videos, my photos, and my joy with my friends and family all over the world and, if YouTube won’t let me do it, I’ll find someone who will.
Enter Vimeo. I was very happy to see that the very first bullet point under the Content Policy of their Uploading Guidelines states, “No sexually illicit material or porn. Non-sexual nudity is okay.” And why shouldn’t it be?! Prohibiting bathing babies and breastfeeding mothers is tantamount to deleting all photos of people wearing flip-flops just because 1.1% of the population has a foot fetish. I don’t need YouTube to protect my family. That’s my job.
So I’m considering making the switch. But I need to make sure that the quality of my hosted videos will be as good as (or better than) with YouTube. So here are two videos from the exact same source, one hosted on YouTube, one on Vimeo. Please have a look and let me know if you notice any difference between the two – either in image/sound quality or ease of use in the user interface. Your feedback will help me make my decision: